Par kluseba le 13 Septembre 2011 à 00:19
I can't understand the brilliant and positive critics all around this movie. Has anyone seen the Asian action movies which Tarantion want to honour? Or is everybody thinking that one can't give an bad review to a film that has been directed by someone who has created so well received cult movies as "Reservoir dogs" or "Pulp Fiction" or who has been involved in "From dusk 'til dawn"? Well, I think that the whole story of this film is just very superficial (simple story of vengeance), has many lacks of logic (as the main actress escapes from the hospital after having been in a coma)and is mostly focused on some gore effects and exaggerated fight scenes without any Asian elegance or philosophy (the almost endless fight scene around the fountain of blood). Sometimes, I think that an aggressive teenager who likes some gore and splatter horror movies and some fight movies in the key of Arnold Schwarzenegger or Jean-Claude van Damme rather that Ti Lung or David Chiang had the idea of such a movie, but not a adult who knows the whole genre and has an IQ of 160.
To really evaluate this film you might have seen the original Asian movies that inspired Quentin Tarantino. This kind of filming was an art for itself, while "Kill Bill" is just a superficial gore movie with a lot of dead people, fight scenes and wanna-be cool dialogues.
Give those Asian films a chance and forget about this silly opera of violence from a director who has done a few nice movies in the past and lives from its reputation...
Par kluseba le 13 Septembre 2011 à 00:15
First of all, I was a huge fan of the first movie of the series and the second one was much weaker, but still a quite nice and entertaining movie to me.
But this third one is just disappointing. This movie lives only from the great acting of the charismatic Johnny Depp. All other actors look really poor, silly, limited, ordinary and unnecessary next to him.
The story is quite weak, the movie way too long and it all seems to be too forced on some action elements and a showdown with some visual effects, but this is all destroying the charm of the first two movies and the originality of the first one.
I've read somewhere that there would be a fourth part. Maybe the studios want to make some money, because the fans and critics can't be happy about a new film after having watched this soulless and superficial movie. My three stars are for Johnny Depp, forget about the rest...
Suivre le flux RSS des articles de cette rubrique
Suivre le flux RSS des commentaires de cette rubrique